Evernorth Therapists in Indiana

Finding a therapist who accepts Evernorth insurance can make mental health support more affordable and convenient. With 74 verified therapists in Indiana who accept Evernorth insurance, you can filter by therapeutic approaches such as cognitive behavioral therapy, mindfulness-based therapy, and supportive counseling to address issues like stress, anxiety, or relationship challenges. Each Grow Therapy-verified therapist listed below is currently welcoming new clients and has availability within the next 30 days, ensuring you have timely access to quality care within your Evernorth insurance plan.

Find therapists near you in

Indianapolis

Availability updated: 7/10/2025

Cheri Counterman

(she/her)

Cheri Counterman, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
12 years of experience
Virtual
Are you ready to make a change? I'm Cheri Counterman, LCSW. I've been working as a therapist and medical social worker for over a decade. I've worked with clients who have had a wide range of concerns like depression, anxiety, relationship issues, self-esteem issues, trauma, and many more. For therapeutic modalities, I specialize in EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) but also utilize other forms of therapy like CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) and MI (Motivational Interviewing). I am passionate about learning new therapeutic skills and attend yearly trainings to stay on top of new evidence-based therapies to help my clients. I know that asking for help can be one of the most vulnerable things we do as humans. That's why it's so important to me to make sure your time with me is as comfortable as possible. My goal is to create an open, safe space where you can feel supported in whatever you need from me. I believe that all people are valuable and deserve love and support no matter what they've been through. Everyone has their own unique story and journey through life; my job is not only to listen but also to help guide you toward healing your mind, body and spirit so that you can live the life you're meant to live!

Samantha Meadows

(she/her)

Samantha Meadows, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
4 years of experience
Virtual
Hello! I began my social work journey in 2006 and have been working in the mental health field since I obtained my MSW in 2008. As a clinical social worker I have thoroughly enjoyed the privilege of helping individuals identify and address many mental health concerns and move towards the life they most desire. I am passionate about addressing the stigma around addictions and serious mental illness and I believe the best way to begin any mental health journey of recovery is with compassion and understanding. I work from a cognitive-behavioral perspective and I use a strengths-based orientation of empowerment to work with adults and couples. I feel that we are already our best selves-we just need some help letting go of the survival skills we've taken on to get through the toughest times in our lives. I have spent several years working exclusively with homeless veterans and individuals struggling with addiction, and this has given me additional perspective and insight into the needs of some of our most vulnerable populations. I am an advocate, an accountability partner, an empath and your greatest cheerleader. I'm excited to help you rediscover your best self and to claim the life you deserve.

Brandy Miller

Brandy Miller, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
10 years of experience
Virtual
When life becomes challenging, when self-care is slipping away, or when stress and struggles seem overwhelming or paralyzing, I want you to know that you are not alone. You are stronger than you realize. You can discover (or rediscover) your “authentic self” even when it seems impossible or unsurmountable. I am here to help. Together, we can assess what your authentic needs and how to achieve them in mind, body, emotions, spirit and action. I’m here to guide, educate, and empower you. My treatment approach is one of curiosity and compassion so that during our sessions, you are free to slow down and safely practice mindfulness and self-care. Together, we will decide which types of interventions work best for you: talk therapy, faith-based, practical problem-solving, trauma-informed care, or creative techniques like art or narrative approaches. We will explore your inner thought-life through mindfulness and cognitive work. We will identify skills, strengths, and supports that can grow through patient practice between sessions. With evidence-based techniques, we will find and navigate paths so you can reclaim joy and walk in peace. I am privileged to walk alongside you during your journey. Peace and hope are possible and sustainable. You deserve to take care of yourself. You will be stronger on the other side.

Christy L Walters

(she/her)

Christy L Walters, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
17 years of experience
Virtual
I am a licensed mental health counselor, with 15 years experience working with ages 6-99. I have worked with Trauma victims, Anxiety issues, Depression, self esteem, domestic violence victims. Teenage/coming of age issues and Grief/Loss, Life changes. I have training in Trauma Focused - Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). Dialectical Behavioral Therapy, Motivational Interviewing, and MIndfulness therapies. Which means (lol) I am an Experienced Licensed and trained professional that meets clients where their need is and works with client as a Team to resolve past issues and develop new, healthy pathways that they can take with them to grow.

Sydni Brown

(she/her)

Sydni Brown, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
6 years of experience
Virtual
Hello! I’m a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) based in Indiana with a Master’s Degree from Indiana University with 6 years of clinical experience. I have a strong background working with children and am now expanding my focus to support adults. My goal is to help clients heal from past experiences, build resilience, and create meaningful change in their lives.

Soneela Choudhry

(she/her)

Soneela Choudhry, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
3 years of experience
Virtual
Hi, I'm Soneela! I am a mental health therapist who specializes in working with teens and adults navigating anxiety, life transitions, relationship issues, and stressors. My goal is to create a warm and culturally sensitive space where you feel truly heard. Life can throw curveballs at us but together, we’ll uncover patterns, build self-awareness, and help you move forward with clarity and confidence.

Kimberly Winkel

(she/her)

Kimberly Winkel, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
40 years of experience
Virtual
Hello and welcome! I understand that life can be tough at times. I am dedicated to helping people, like you, navigate through difficult periods. We all reach a point where we need support and guidance. I am committed to supporting you on your path to healing. Together, we will create personalized goals that cater to your individual needs and preferences. Through this process, you will gain a deeper understanding of yourself and develop tools to maintain a healthy work/life balance in the future.

Ruth Dilley

(she/her)

Ruth Dilley, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
4 years of experience
Virtual
Hi, I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW). I received my degree from Indiana University and currently live in Michigan on a horse farm. I have over 4 years of experience seeing clients in an office setting, or via telehealth for traditional therapy, as well as play therapy, and animal assisted therapy for in person sessions. I see teens, and adults for telehealth, to assist with developing coping skills, insight, and improved self-care to live life with greater ease, and less distress.

Amanda Hawkins

Amanda Hawkins, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
15 years of experience
Virtual
Are your relationships with others not what you would like them to be? Do you feel like you are not living up to your "full potential" and serving your life purpose? The stressors of life can weigh us down at times. I want to help you take the first step toward making lasting change in your life. Together we will identify strengths as well as life challenges that will help you gain a better understanding of yourself and your relationships.

Haley Milholland

(she/her)

Haley Milholland, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
5 years of experience
Virtual
As a single mother raising three young children, I have honed my skills in assisting individuals navigate life’s challenges. With three years of experience in private practice, I have cultivated a deep passion for helping others find fulfillment and peace amidst adversity. Prior to my practice, I gained extensive experience in community mental health settings and served as a clinical support supervisor in an inpatient women’s rehabilitation facility. When not engaged in my professional pursuits, I enjoy spending time with my children, our blue heeler, Lilly, reading, running, and embarking on adventures with friends and family. I firmly believe that the cornerstone of a fulfilling life lies in cultivating a sense of contentment that allows individuals to cope effectively with life’s obstacles.

Taylor Lewis

(she/her)

Taylor Lewis, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy

Frequently rebooked

LCSW
5 years of experience
Virtual
Hello, I'm Taylor. My focus is on empowering individuals to live the life they want. Seeking therapy can be an overwhelming experience in itself. My focus is meeting clients where they are at and outlining a plan of action for tackling difficult mental health issues including anxiety, depression etc. My specialties include: fertility/family planning issues, chronic illness, rare disease, anxiety, interpersonal/relationship difficulties and life changes/adjustments. Together, my goal is to create a safe and healing place for you to get where you want to be. Compassion, empathy and evidence-based therapeutic techniques are the foundation of my practice. Let's work towards getting you where you want to be!

Megan Waters

(she/her)

Megan Waters, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
6 years of experience
Virtual
Do you often feel overwhelmed with life? Or do you feel that something from your past is keeping you stuck? I can help with anxiety, depression, past trauma, negative self talk, relationship issues and more. I have found great success with walking along side the people I work with to help them move from where they are to where they want to be…wherever that might be! I’m nonjudgmental and accepting of all walks of life- LGBTQIA+ individuals are welcome. I didn’t get into therapy to “fix” people, I use my practice to guide and help find new ways of doing or looking at things. I love being able to track the progress my clients make when they utilize the skills we’ve talked about in session. I use a mix of Motivational Interviewing and Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for most cases. For those suffering from PTSD, I use my Certified Clinical Trauma Professional training which includes somatic (body) work along with narrative work, all of which is grounded in the neuroscience of trauma. I have my Perinatal Mental Health Certificate as well, meaning I am aptly trained to help with anyone transitioning into new parenthood. I’m not overly concerned with labels and diagnoses, I’m just here to help you make changes to function and feel better day to day. If you think my approach sounds like it would help you, please reach out and we can schedule our first session to determine if we’ll be a good fit to work together moving forward. I genuinely can’t wait to meet you.

Ashley Stowe

Ashley Stowe, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
5 years of experience
Virtual
Hello! I’m a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) based in Indiana with five years of experience supporting clients through life’s transitions. I earned my Master’s in Social Work from Indiana University and recently became Perinatal Mental Health Certified (PMH-C). I’m deeply passionate about maternal mental health and committed to walking alongside women through every stage of their journey—whether you’re preparing for motherhood, currently pregnant, navigating postpartum, or working to rediscover and reconnect with yourself. My goal is to create a safe, affirming space where you feel seen, supported, and empowered.

Rachel Klekot

(she/her)

Rachel Klekot, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
10 years of experience
Virtual
I am a sex-positive, LGBTQIA-affirmative, polyamory-friendly, and kink-aware therapist. I work with individuals across a broad spectrum, providing a safe and supportive space to explore life challenges and changes. I offer compassionate, collaborative, and non-judgmental therapy, where we will explore both your struggles and successes, learning together how you want to move through life with greater confidence, clarity, and self-acceptance. .

Porsche Collins

(she/her)

Porsche Collins, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
15 years of experience
Virtual
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker practicing in the state of NC, SC, GA, CT, MA and IN. I am the sole therapist of Empathic Hues Counseling and Consultation, PLLC. My practice was created to help adults dealing with depression, anxiety and needing guidance with adjusting to to a change in quality of life. I hope to help individuals find peace needed to have more control over their lives and confidently overcome challenges. My goal is to help you understand “you” as well as focus on developing your internal and external strengths.

LaDortha Mitchell-Young

(she/her)

LaDortha Mitchell-Young, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
14 years of experience
Virtual
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) based in Indianapolis, Indiana, with over ten years of experience working with children, teens, and adults. My goal is to support you in navigating difficult emotions by teaching healthy coping skills that foster self-love and self-worth. Together, we can work toward building a positive self-image that enhances your ability to form fulfilling and meaningful relationships.

Dani Abdullah

(she/they)

Dani Abdullah, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
10 years of experience
Virtual
Hey! I'm a Licensed Clinical Social Worker with 10 years of experience working in mental health in Indiana. I received my Psychology degree from Dominican University and my Social Work degree from Indiana University. I love working with kids from ages 6 and up, but I also really love helping young adults with their transitions into adulthood which is typically 18-24. No matter your age, I want to work with someone who is ready to work on themselves!

Jessica Rae Montgomery

(she/her)

Jessica Rae Montgomery, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
5 years of experience
Virtual
Jessica Rae Montgomery (She/Her/Hers), Clinical Psychotherapist. I have dedicated my career to working with individuals with serious mental illness, specializing in crisis care and psychosis. I have worked hand in hand with providers at The Johns Hopkins Hospital, Eskenazi Health, and Penn Medicine. I have provided psychotherapy and group services in a coordinated specialty care team and worked in the emergency room and hospital units providing psychological care. I earned my Masters of Science in Clinical Mental Health through The Johns Hopkins University and Bachelor of Arts in Psychology from Purdue University Calumet. I am a Licensed Professional Counselor in PA and Licensed Mental Health Counselor in IN.

Audrey Elam

(She)

Audrey Elam, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
9 years of experience
Virtual
I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) with over nine years of experience supporting adults of all ages in mental health and addiction treatment settings. I specialize in helping individuals who are struggling with depression, anxiety and substance use. My approach is warm, collaborative, and solution-focused, and I strive to meet people where they are in their journey. I am passionate about creating a safe, non-judgmental space where you can show up as you are. I believe in each person’s capacity for growth and transformation, and I feel honored to walk alongside my clients as they navigate meaningful change using evidence-based practices.

Candace Papke

(she/her)

Candace Papke, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
10 years of experience
Virtual
Hi! I'm Candace. Do you ever feel like an island, where nobody truly understands you? When you attempt to express your needs, it often leaves you questioning your sanity and making you feel isolated. As you scroll through social media, it seems like everyone else has it all figured out. Despite your best efforts, you feel trapped and stagnant. Together we can navigate through it. You are not alone. As a mother of 3, I understand how difficult it can be to navigate life as a parent, maintain a work/life balance, and curate healthy relationships. It can be exhausting! Through my training and experience, I specialize in supporting other women with their emotional struggles and empowering them to find solutions within themselves.

Payal Sud

Payal Sud, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
15 years of experience
Virtual
Hello! I am a South Asian, first-generation licensed clinical social worker( LCSW) based in Illinois. I have been in the field for over 20 years. I help marginalized communities navigate the world and put their mind, body, and soul back together. I utilize holistic and integrative methods to assist individuals in their mental health journey in a safe and comfortable space.

Belinda Paulicin

Belinda Paulicin, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
20 years of experience
Virtual
Hello! I’m Belinda Paulicin, a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) serving Florida and Indiana with over 20 years of experience. I hold a doctorate and master’s degree in clinical social work. I have advanced certification and training in evidence-based and trauma-focused interventions. I work with families, individuals, and communities from various backgrounds. My focus is on building capacity and resilience to cope with life challenges.

Jenae Hershberger

Jenae Hershberger, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
10 years of experience
Virtual
Hi, I'm Jenae! Ever feel like you're carrying the world on your shoulders, thinking you have to handle everything alone, only to feel suffocated by it all? It's a common struggle, believe me. But here's the scoop: counseling isn't about getting a to-do list or being labeled "weak" for reaching out. It's about finding a cozy spot to unpack what's on your mind and in your heart. It's a sanctuary where you can just be you, no judgments or expectations. So, if you're feeling overwhelmed, know this: seeking help is a brave move towards healing. You're not alone in this journey. I'm here to guide you towards understanding your thoughts, emotions, and actions better. With an authentic, easygoing, and even enjoyable approach, I create a safe, judgment-free zone where you can freely talk about your concerns. Together, we'll develop a roadmap towards a more fulfilling life that aligns with your values and desires. If you're feeling the weight of stress in any area of life – personal, relational, familial, professional – I assist you in understanding the impact emotionally, physically, & mentally. You'll discover how to leverage your brain's capabilities to navigate life more effectively. Let's turn current problems into growth opportunities!

Rachel Richard

(she/her)

Rachel Richard, LMHC - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMHC
27 years of experience
Virtual
Hi, I'm Rachel Richard! With over 25 years of experience as a licensed counselor, I specialize in helping clients manage anxiety and depression, overcome trauma, and navigate life's everyday challenges. I hold a Master's Degree in Community/Mental Health Counseling from the University of Cincinnati and I am licensed in Ohio, Kentucky, and Indiana. My commitment lies in providing evidence-based practices that empower clients to manage their emotions, reduce unhelpful thought patterns, confidently cope with life's challenges, and achieve their goals. My approach is strengths-based and solution-focused, with specialties in Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Acceptance and Commitment Therapy, and Solution-Focused Brief Therapy. For those open to a holistic approach, I also incorporate Somatic Therapy to connect mind and body.

Barbie Popa

(she/her)

Barbie Popa, LCSW - Indiana Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
10 years of experience
Virtual
Hi there! I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW) based in Valparaiso, Indiana. I earned my Masters Degree in Social Work from Indiana University-Purdue University (IUPUI) and Social Work/Business undergraduate degrees from Valparaiso University. I have been practicing for over nine years. Before that time, I was a self-employed business owner in the field of software sales and consulting. I work in community mental health and addictions, serving a population struggling with addiction and co-occurring mental health disorders. I mainly work with adults and adolescents. My focus is on creating a safe space to collaborate in the therapeutic experience; helping you to feel better faster!

Frequently asked questions

Why filter by Indiana rather than a city like Indianapolis?

When looking for online therapy, you can see anyone that is credentialed in the state. We want you to find the best fit, therefore, Grow Therapy shows available therapists across Indiana from Fort Wayne to Evansville! If you’d rather see someone in-person, you can change the filter from virtual and find a therapist near you in Indiana.

Will my therapist take Evernorth?

Yes! If you use Evernorth you’ll be asked to verify your Member ID at the time you book the appointment. However, if you don’t have Evernorth you can select cash. Our therapists will have their cost of appointment on their profile. Individual session costs will vary.

How does the Specialty Filter work? Can I find a therapist that focuses on Women's Issues?

The specialty filter is optional. You don’t need to check any boxes to see a provider. However, fit is very important when selecting an online therapist. If you have knowledge or experience to recognize what specialties you may need. For example, your selected specialty, Women's Issues, is filtering therapists in Indiana that work with patients with similar concerns.

Why use Gender, Age, and Identities filters?

Finding a provider with a similar life experience can be beneficial because it can be easier to establish rapport and potentially be understood quicker and clearer.

What to expect during your first session?

Your first therapy session is for you and your therapist to meet each other and to ask any questions that you have about the counseling process. This is where you can expect your therapist to do the same as they will ask questions to gain insight into your specific situation. In this first session the therapist is doing their part to gather as much information so they can better assess if they are able to meet your therapeutic needs.

Depending upon your provider's specialty, you may also discuss the methods the therapist will use. For additional information on therapy methods, please visit the Grow Therapy Help Center. Some people feel nervous before their first appointment, and that is totally normal! Coming prepared with a list of questions for your therapist may help. Remember, you're taking a brave step by seeking therapy, and it is okay to be nervous as you try something new.