Therapist red flags to watch for and when it’s time to find someone new
This article talks about depression, self-harm, or suicide. If you are experiencing a mental health crisis or are thinking about harming yourself or others, contact the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (call, text, or chat) for 24/7 confidential support, call 911, or go to the nearest emergency department. If you are LGBTQ+ and experiencing suicidal thoughts, you can reach the Trevor Project at www.thetrevorproject.org/get-help/
Not every therapist is going to be the right fit for you, and that’s okay. Therapy is a personal process. Just like in any relationship, some partnerships click and others don’t. Sometimes, the issue is about personal style. Maybe you prefer direct advice, and your therapist speaks in vague or abstract ways. Other times, the concern is more serious, like a lack of boundaries or unethical behavior.
These concerns are sometimes called therapist red flags. They are signs that your therapist may not be meeting your needs in a safe, professional, or effective way.
Key takeaways
- Not all red flags are the same – Some mean the therapist may not be the best fit (“could be better”), while others are serious signs it’s time to leave (“time to reconsider”).
- When it could be better – Poor listening, weak boundaries, outdated knowledge, or a lack of trust can signal the therapist just isn’t the right match for you.
- When it’s time to reconsider – Unclear credentials, unprofessional behavior, broken confidentiality, or harmful conduct are serious concerns that make therapy unsafe.
- Abuse is never okay – Threats, judgment, discriminatory comments, or anything that leaves you feeling afraid or ashamed are red flags that require leaving immediately.
- Before ending therapy – It can help to raise your concerns first. A good therapist will listen and work with you. Dismissiveness or defensiveness is a sign to move on.
- You deserve safe, supportive care – If a therapist crosses serious boundaries, you can report them to your state licensing board. And remember, the right therapist is out there, and you deserve one who helps you feel heard and respected.
We’ve grouped the most common red flags into two types to help with your search:
- “Could be better” flags: These might mean that another therapist could be a better fit. Since therapy takes time, energy, and money, a good match can make a big difference.
- “Time to reconsider” flags: These are signs of unprofessional, unethical, or harmful behavior. If you see them, it’s best to end the relationship. You can also report serious issues to your state’s licensing board.
When it could be better…
When therapy isn’t harmful but doesn’t feel helpful, it might be a sign that something’s missing. These red flags suggest the therapist may not be the right fit.
Red flag #1: Poor listening or lack of empathy
When you talk, does your therapist seem to truly understand you? Do they seem curious about your life and experiences? You should feel supported, especially when you open up about something vulnerable. Receiving attention, validation, and care in those moments is part of what makes therapy healing.
Red flags in this area may include:
- Dismissing your feelings
- Ignoring your concerns
- Minimizing your experience
- Talking over you or dominating sessions
Red flag #2: Not having a clear specialty
Most therapists have a focus. It can be a specific condition, population, or therapy style. For example, they might specialize in eating disorders, couples therapy, or trauma work.
If a therapist doesn’t clearly identify their specialty, it can be harder to know whether they have the skills or experience to support your specific needs. When looking online, you might see therapists list 20+ specialties. Focus on the first 3 to 5. These are usually the areas where they have the most training and experience.
Red flag #3: Weak or missing boundaries
Healthy boundaries are a key part of therapy. In your first session, your therapist should clearly explain what you can expect, including the following:
- Goals you’ll work on together
- The role they’ll play
- The role you’ll play
- Limits of the relationship
For example, you might say, “I want to work on my anxiety in public spaces.”
Your therapist might respond with something like, “I’m here to support you, and I’ll never push you past your comfort zone.”
You might agree to stay open during sessions and speak up if you need a break. They should also clarify limits, such as not interacting outside of sessions unless it’s therapy-related communication, such as scheduling or emergencies.
If your therapist hasn’t clearly defined these boundaries or regularly crosses them, it’s important to bring this up in a session. If they dismiss your concerns or continue the behavior, it may be a sign to look for a better fit.
Red flag #4: Limited knowledge in important areas
It helps when your therapist understands your background and current situation. If a therapist doesn’t understand key parts of your identity or life, they might struggle to connect with you. This can limit the support you truly deserve.
Make a short list of qualities you’re looking for. This might include language, culture, or family experience. Doing a consultation first can help you decide if the therapist is a good match.
Red flag #5: Outdated knowledge
Now, even if a therapist has worked with people like you before, that experience may not be recent. For example, they might have treated eating disorders 15 years ago. But if they haven’t kept up with current practices, it may not be a good fit.
Licensed therapists are typically required to complete a set number of continuing education hours each year. You can ask how they stay current with new research or treatment approaches.
Red flag #6: Trouble building trust
Trust takes time, but it should start with comfort. Some people like to chat before diving in. Others prefer to get straight to the work. Your therapist should pick up on what helps you feel at ease. If that connection doesn’t start to grow, it can be hard to open up or make real progress in therapy.
If their style feels off, that doesn’t always mean they’re unethical. But it might mean there’s someone else out there who’s a better fit for you.
When it’s time to reconsider…
When therapy causes harm or crosses important boundaries, it’s no longer safe or supportive. These signs suggest it’s time to end the relationship and take steps to protect your well-being.
Red flag #7: Missing or unclear credentials
Therapists must be licensed in your state to provide you with care. This means they’ve had training, supervision, and passed exams. Checking a therapist’s license helps make sure you’re getting safe, qualified care. To check a therapist’s licensing, look at the letters after their name. These show their license type which may be one or more of:
- ACD or LADC: Licensed Addiction Counselor
- CATC: Certified Addiction Treatment Counselor
- LPC or LPCC: Licensed Professional Counselor
- LCSW: Licensed Clinical Social Worker
- LMFT: Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist
- MD or DO: Psychiatrist
- Ph.D., PsyD, EdD: Psychologist
Use your state’s licensing board database to confirm their status.
Red flag #8: Unprofessional behavior
Your therapist should treat you with respect. They should show up on time and respond to your messages. They should also focus the session on your needs, not theirs. You should never feel manipulated, judged, or unsafe.
Red flag #9: Breaking confidentiality
Your therapist is required to protect your privacy. They can’t share your personal details without your permission.
Some dual relationships like having mutual acquaintances can be ethically navigated with clear boundaries. But when the dual role interferes with your care, or creates a conflict of interest, it becomes a serious concern.
The “Duty to warn” exception
Exceptions to confidentiality do exist and therapists may need to report certain situations. This is referred to as “duty to warn.” These include plans to harm yourself or others, abuse, emergencies, or court orders. Rules vary by state. The National Conference on State Legislatures offers state-by-state guidance on mental health professionals’ duty to warn.
Red flag #10: Abusive or harmful behavior
Sometimes, abuse in therapy isn’t easy to spot, especially if you’ve experienced abuse before. But if something feels wrong, trust your instincts and get help. Therapy should never leave you feeling afraid or ashamed. Therapists should never:
- Use threats or hurtful language
- Show extreme emotions (like yelling)
- Say racist, sexist, or demeaning things
- Make you feel scared or unsafe
Red flag #11: Unethical billing
Therapists must bill honestly. You should have a clear understanding of what you’re being charged for. If something seems unclear, it’s okay to ask questions. You can also request a breakdown of your bill. Red flags include:
- Charging for services you didn’t receive
- Charging twice for the same service
- Asking you to pay with non-HIPAA-compliant apps like Venmo or CashApp
Red flag #12: Techniques that don’t work for you
Therapy should support your healing process over time, even if progress feels slow or nonlinear. If you’re not seeing meaningful change, it’s okay to ask about alternative approaches.
It’s also important to consider whether your therapist’s style fits your needs. Do you feel more supported with structure, or do you prefer a looser, open-ended conversation? Even if a therapist is experienced and well-intentioned, they still might not be the right match for you, and that’s okay.
Red flag #13: Power imbalance or controlling behavior
While therapy involves a natural power imbalance, a skilled therapist will work to minimize this dynamic by collaborating with you and respecting your autonomy.
You should feel like a partner in your care. Your therapist should respect your goals and let you take the lead. They’re there to guide, not to command.
Red flag #14: Feeling unheard or invalidated
You deserve to feel seen and understood in therapy. If that’s not happening over time, it’s okay to move on. When your therapist doesn’t truly listen or validate your experiences, it can damage the trust and safety needed for therapy to work.
Unconscious bias is real, but it should never shape your care. If you feel judged for your identity or experiences, that’s a serious issue.
Before ending the relationship
Therapy can feel hard sometimes. Growth often involves discomfort. But feeling unsafe is different and is always a reason to leave. If you’re unsure, here are three questions to ask yourself:
- Are you avoiding conflict? Therapy is a relationship, and conflict can happen. If something hurts you, try bringing it up. A good therapist should listen and work to repair the relationship.
- Have you given feedback? Therapists can make mistakes. Letting them know how you feel gives them a chance to make things right and gives you a chance to speak up in a safe space.
- How did they respond? A caring therapist will hear your feedback, talk it through with you, and try to do better. But if they dismiss or ignore you, that’s a sign it’s time to leave.
Finding Your Path Forward
Remember that seeking therapy is an act of courage and self-care. Whether you’re just starting your search or considering a change, trust yourself to recognize what feels right and what doesn’t. The therapeutic relationship is unique and deeply personal – what works wonderfully for one person might not be the right fit for another, and that’s completely normal.
If you do need to end a therapeutic relationship, know that this doesn’t reflect poorly on you or mean that therapy won’t work. It simply means you’re advocating for yourself and your healing journey.
When you do find the right therapist, you’ll likely notice the difference: sessions will feel collaborative, you’ll feel heard and respected, and over time, you’ll start to see meaningful progress toward your goals.
Your mental health matters, and you deserve care that feels safe, professional, and genuinely helpful. Don’t settle for less than that. The right therapeutic partnership can be truly transformative, and taking the time to find it is an investment in your well-being that’s absolutely worth making.