Cigna Therapists in New Jersey

Finding a therapist who accepts Cigna insurance can make mental health care more accessible and manageable within your budget. With 5 verified therapists in New Jersey who accept Cigna insurance, you can filter by therapeutic approaches such as cognitive behavioral therapy, acceptance and commitment therapy, and supportive counseling to address concerns like anxiety, depression, or life transitions. Each Grow Therapy-verified therapist listed below is currently accepting new clients and has availability within the next 30 days, ensuring timely, quality support tailored to your needs within your Cigna insurance coverage.

Availability updated: 7/2/2025

Greg Caiafa

Greg Caiafa, LCSW - New Jersey Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
6 years of experience
In-person
106 Apple St, T...
I know anxiety and depression. I know how it feels to fall down over and over and believe like you're destined to fall again. I also know firsthand how changing our thinking can help us to overcome even the most daunting challenges. I've helped countless people make significant progress in every aspect of their lives. I utilize established modalities like CBT, ACT and Motivational Interviewing, but I also know the value of listening.

NatashaLee Blair

(she/her)

NatashaLee Blair, LCSW - New Jersey Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
15 years of experience
In-person
1500 Kings High...
Hello, I'm Natasha Lee and I am looking forward to getting to know you. You've already taken the first step in seeking therapy and should be proud of yourself. It takes bravery to seek help and express vulnerability. Through empathy and compassion, I utilize evidence-based practices to empower, motivate, and encourage you to become the best version of yourself you can be. I will work with you hand in hand to assist you with learning effective techniques to manage your emotions, anxiety, depression, trauma, and daily life stressors. I have extensive experience working with children, adolescents, and adults from diverse backgrounds. I offer in-person sessions as well as tele-therapy. Whether you are seeking therapy individually for yourself or a loved one or seeking to improve your relationship or family dynamics, I am here to help you fill your toolbox with the essential mechanisms needed for positive change. I love being a therapist and being able to provide an outlet and safe space to heal.

Ivelisse Reyes

(she/her)

Ivelisse Reyes, LPC - New Jersey Therapist at Grow Therapy
LPC
20 years of experience
In-person
2 N Rd, Warren,...
Hello! Hola! Welcome to New Day New Beginnings, LLC. My name is Ivelisse and I am a bilingual therapist with over 20 years of experience in the mental health field working with teens and adults (young and older). I am a faith-informed (Christian Catholic) therapist and I integrate biblical truth and evidence based techniques in my practice. However, you determine if religion/spirituality will be part of your sessions. I am currently providing in person and telehealth services, working with older teens ages 16+ and adults (18+). My approach is eclectic, insight-oriented, with a focus in strength based and client-centered, because there is no “one size fits all” as we are all unique individuals. Feel free to visit my website: www.newdaynewbeginningsllc.com

Leah Yau

(she/her)

Leah Yau, LCSW - New Jersey Therapist at Grow Therapy
LCSW
20 years of experience
In-person
43 Maple Avenue...
Sometimes we experience life events that cause us significant distress, sadness or anger. Other times, our life is not going in the direction we wish but don't know why and don't know what to do. Still other times, our hectic lives leave us unable to nurture our relationships and families the way we want to... I can help you create stronger relationships with your loved ones, strengthen your self esteem, and help you remove barriers to achieve your personal goals. Beginning Anew, LLC believes the cornerstone of therapeutic success is feeling understood and accepted. We can help you cope with a distressing life event, find a healthier and more satisfying approach to life issues and ultimately pave a better path to happiness! I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker with over 15 years of experience working with individuals, couples, and families. I earned my Masters of Science in Social Work from Columbia University, and my Bachelor of Arts in Psychology from Rutgers University. I have a diverse background working in employee assistance, university hospital mental health, discharge planning, psychiatric inpatient, substance abuse treatment and private practice. I approach my work with a strength-based cognitive behavioral perspective. I am a long time member of the National Association of Social Workers.

Julie Fitzick

(she/her)

Julie Fitzick, LMFT - New Jersey Therapist at Grow Therapy
LMFT
6 years of experience
In-person
2401 Bay Ave, O...
As an practicing clinician since 2020, I bring experience from community mental health, the educational system, and private practice. I've worked with individuals, couples, and families of all ages, tailoring evidence-based approaches to support each client's unique journey toward growth & healing. Life can feel overwhelming, but you don’t have to face challenges alone. I provide compassionate, personalized therapy for individuals, couples, and families at all stages of life. Whether you’re navigating emotional regulation, parenting struggles, grief, ADHD, anxiety, depression, or relationship challenges, I’m here to support you.
These are all the providers we have at this time based on your selections. We're constantly adding new providers to our site. Try adjusting your filters to see available providers.

Frequently asked questions

Why filter by New Jersey rather than a city like Newark?

When looking for online therapy, you can see anyone that is credentialed in the state. We want you to find the best fit, therefore, Grow Therapy shows available therapists across New Jersey from Jersey City to Paterson! If you’d rather see someone in-person, you can change the filter from virtual and find a therapist near you in New Jersey.

Will my therapist take Cigna?

Yes! If you use Cigna you’ll be asked to verify your Member ID at the time you book the appointment. However, if you don’t have Cigna you can select cash. Our therapists will have their cost of appointment on their profile. Individual session costs will vary.

How does the Specialty Filter work? Can I find a therapist that focuses on Peer Relationships?

The specialty filter is optional. You don’t need to check any boxes to see a provider. However, fit is very important when selecting an online therapist. If you have knowledge or experience to recognize what specialties you may need. For example, your selected specialty, Peer Relationships, is filtering therapists in New Jersey that work with patients with similar concerns.

Why use Gender, Age, and Identities filters?

Finding a provider with a similar life experience can be beneficial because it can be easier to establish rapport and potentially be understood quicker and clearer.

What to expect during your first session?

Your first therapy session is for you and your therapist to meet each other and to ask any questions that you have about the counseling process. This is where you can expect your therapist to do the same as they will ask questions to gain insight into your specific situation. In this first session the therapist is doing their part to gather as much information so they can better assess if they are able to meet your therapeutic needs.

Depending upon your provider's specialty, you may also discuss the methods the therapist will use. For additional information on therapy methods, please visit the Grow Therapy Help Center. Some people feel nervous before their first appointment, and that is totally normal! Coming prepared with a list of questions for your therapist may help. Remember, you're taking a brave step by seeking therapy, and it is okay to be nervous as you try something new.