Licensed to practice in Indiana and accepts 41 insurances. Specializes in Anxiety, Depression, Grief and 10 more.
Rebecca Muthig
(she/her)
About me
I have worked as a therapist for over 18 years. I previously worked in clinics and am comfortable dealing with nearly every kind of mental health issue. In recent years, I have become particularly interested in helping those dealing with reoccuring or chronic mental health issues and helping those who help people dealing with mental health concerns. My goal is to equip clients to deal with whatever they are facing in a calmer, more effective manner.
Get to know me
In our first session together, here's what you can expect
In our first session, I want to get to know who you are and what you are currently facing that is causing you distress. I might ask some questions to get us started, then I will listen. I will do everything I can to make you feel comfortable; it can be daunting to speak to a stranger about hard things and I want to make that easier.
The biggest strengths that I bring into our sessions
I love my work; I truly believe there is nothing too hard to face when given the tools and the support needed. I like to use humor where appropriate, and I bring compassion to the unique situation you are facing. Every person has strength, courage, beauty and creativity in them, sometimes undiscovered. Together, we will unlock your potential to face what you need to face with grace.
The clients I'm best positioned to serve
Are you feeling overwhelmed, stressed, burnt out and worried? Do you feel the things you enjoy are out of reach, or you have lost touch with what that could be? Living a life in which you feel fulfilled in some way, finding pleasure in small things even when the big things are hard, feeling connected to others: these are things everyone needs and deserves. I want to help you feel better, more stable, more fulfilled, and hopefully happier. We cannot avoid problems, setbacks or negative events in life, but we can face them with grace and courage.
Specialties
Top specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Grief
Other specialties
Coping Skills
Dissociative Disorders
First Responders/Healthcare Workers
Health/Medical Issues
Life Transitions
Mood Disorders
Older Adults
Phobias
Self Esteem
Serious Mental Illness
Identifies as
Woman
Serves ages
Adults (18 to 64)
Elders (65 and above)
Teenagers (13 to 17)
Licensed in
Indiana
Accepts
Aetna
Aetna - ASR Health Benefits
Aetna - Allied Benefits
Aetna - Lucent Health
Aetna - Luminare
Aetna - Moda
Aetna - WebTPA
Aetna – HealthEZ
All Savers
Amerihealth Administrators
Anthem
Blue Cross Blue Shield
Independence Administrators
Independence Blue Cross
Arlo
AvMed
Cash - $100 per session
Centivo
Cigna
Cigna - HealthEZ
EAP:Cigna
EAP:Evernorth
EAP:UnitedHealthcare/Optum
Evernorth
GTEB
Golden Rule
Harvard Pilgrim/UnitedHealthcare
Medicaid - Managed Health Services
Managed Health Services (Managed Medicaid)
UnitedHealthcare/Optum
Optum
OptumHealth Complex Medical Conditions
Oscar
Oxford
Surest (formerly Bind)
Tufts Health/Cigna
United Medical Resources
UnitedHealthcare Life Insurance
UnitedHealthcare Shared Services
UnitedHealthcare StudentResources
UnitedHealthcare/Optum - Medicaid
Location
Virtual
My treatment methods
Acceptance and commitment (ACT)
Acknowledging your situation and what isn't working for you is often the first step in finding relief. From there, we look at options and steps you can take to feel better.
Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)
Thought patterns, emotions and your knee jerk responses are so intimately tied that it can often be hard to untangle them on your own. Together, we can get to the root of the problem!
Dialectical Behavior (DBT)
DBT is a toolbox. We can all use the basic methods it teaches to stabilize ourselves and promote well-being.
4 ratings with written reviews
August 8, 2026
She doesn’t just listen, they see me. They hold space for the parts of my story that feel heavy, complicated, or painful, and they do it with a level of compassion that makes it easier to breathe. If you’re looking for a therapist who is deeply empathetic, incredibly skilled, and truly committed to your healing, I couldn’t recommend her more. I’m grateful for every step of this journey with her.
Verified client, age 55-64
March 15, 2026
She is very smart and listens to everything you have to say. Always has me engage in certain what -if scenario s. Very helpful on coming up with solutions to my problems. I appreciate her input and concern.
Verified client, age 55-64
February 25, 2026
Amazing !