Teddy Payne

IMFT (he/him)14 years of experienceNext available
5.0 (127)
Solution oriented
Authentic
Empowering

Welcome! I'm a Marriage and Family Therapist (MFT) licensed in Ohio and Indiana. I received my Master's degree from Liberty University in 2011 and have been practicing for the past 12 years.

I entered this field later in life and it has gifted me the privilege of a broad perspective allowing me to embrace your perspective with dignity and grace.

My focus is relationship therapy, but I have journeyed with a wide variety of people, from adolescents to the elderlI entered this field later in life and it has gifted me the privilege of a broad perspective allowing me to embrace your perspective with dignity and grace.

First session

In our first session, we will have a conversation. I will learn about you and you will be free to ask questions about me. As we set the tone of discovery, we will discuss your reasons for seeking therapy and what you hope to achieve from our time together. At the end of our first session, we will have a general plan that we will review during the next session.

Strengths

I entered this field later in life and it has gifted me the privilege of a broad perspective allowing me to embrace your perspective with dignity and grace.

Ideal clients

The clients who have the greatest success journeying with me are courageous. They are open and honest with themselves. They come ready and willing to explore their strengths and well as their areas to improve. When they get stuck, they do not abandon the journey. They stay with it one step at a time. In the end, they embrace their transformation.

Treatment methods

Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)

You do not have to be stuck. As we journey together, we will discover how your thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are driven by your beliefs. By becoming aware of these connections, we will challenge and change those beliefs. We will work to redeem your past hurts, reshaping them into a foundation of strengths to change. It requires commitment and hard work. But for those who stay, then change will be your reward.

Couples Counseling

Drs. John and Julie Gottman are two of the most well-respected practitioners in relationship counseling. It has been said Dr. John Gottman can predict if a couple will divorce with about 94% accuracy. As a facilitator of Gottman's The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work, I am confident we can improve your relationship satisfaction.

Christian Counseling

As a Graduate of Liberty University's MFT program, I have a strong biblical worldview with a solid background in the many theoretical schools of therapy. Our journey will be a wonderfully powerful connection of theology and therapy that will utilize your Christian principles to help strengthen your mental health.

Culturally Sensitive Therapy

As a person of color, cultural sensitivity is a special area of interest. With post-graduate certificates in MFT and Couples disciplines, I am uniquely qualified to journey with couples who are people of color, in interracial relationships, in intercultural relationships, or have identified other cultural issues as challenging to the relationship.

EMDR

Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing therapy is a robust tool that helps you, the client, to be released from the "stuck" feeling often associated with complex traumas. As a trained EMDR therapist, we will journey together with you as you develop tools to manage the negative thoughts and the involuntary unpleasant feelings you were never meant to carry.

Location

Virtual sessions

Identifies as

  • Black / African American

  • Man

Top specialties

  • Couples Counseling

  • Spirituality

  • Trauma and PTSD

Other specialties

  • Anxiety

  • Chronic Illness

  • Grief

  • Racism

Serves

  • Adults (18 to 64)

  • Elders (65 and above)

Licensed in

  • IndianaLicense 35001809A

  • OhioLicense F.2400392

Accepted insurance

  • Aetna

  • Aetna - ASR Health Benefits

  • Aetna - Allied Benefits

  • Aetna - Gravie

  • Aetna - Lucent Health

  • Aetna - Luminare

  • Aetna - Meritain

  • Aetna - Moda

  • Aetna - WebTPA

  • Aetna – HealthEZ

  • All Savers

  • Ambetter Health

  • Amerihealth Administrators

  • Blue Cross Blue Shield

  • Anthem

  • Independence Blue Cross

  • Independence Administrators

  • Arlo

  • AvMed

  • Cash - $110 per session

  • Centivo

  • Cigna

  • Cigna - HealthEZ

  • EAP:Cigna

  • EAP:Evernorth

  • EAP:UnitedHealthcare/Optum

  • Evernorth

  • GTEB

  • Golden Rule

  • Harvard Pilgrim/UnitedHealthcare

  • Buckeye Health Plan (Managed Medicaid)

  • Medicaid - Buckeye Health Plan

  • Buckeye Health Plan

  • Medical Mutual of Ohio

  • UnitedHealthcare/Optum

  • Optum

  • OptumHealth Complex Medical Conditions

  • Oscar

  • Oxford

  • Surest (formerly Bind)

  • Tufts Health/Cigna

  • United Medical Resources

  • UnitedHealthcare Life Insurance

  • UnitedHealthcare Shared Services

  • UnitedHealthcare StudentResources

  • UnitedHealthcare/Optum - Medicaid

Reviews and ratings

5.0 rating (127)24 reviews
October 26, 2026

Teddy is awesome. Highly recommended!

Verified client, age 25-34Review shared after session 11 with Teddy
September 2, 2026

Teddy is one of the most amazing therapists I have ever come across. I’m very blessed to have him as not only a therapist, but a mentor.

Verified client, age 35-44Review shared after session 1 with Teddy
August 15, 2026

Phenomenal therapist who is not only very knowledgeable but also knows the Lord and the Word of God which is very important to me! He cares in a holistic way with direct communication and it’s truly empowering! I’m so grateful for the work he does with me weekly!

Verified client, age 35-44Review shared after session 8 with Teddy
Schedule 60 min