Licensed to practice in Indiana and accepts 42 insurances. Specializes in Anxiety, Depression, Perinatal Mental Health and 10 more.
Crystal Kelly
(she/her)
About me
Crystal is a Licensed Mental Health Counselor who is a true “Rogerian” at heart. She has a true passion for helping people to be the best versions of themselves. Crystal has 16 years of experience working with children, adolescents, and adults dealing with depression, anxiety, life stressors, and grief. Crystal’s true passion is working with individuals dealing with trauma-related issues. Crystal's passion is to help those who have been impacted by trauma find lasting healing. Crystal is currently trained in Brainspotting, which helps you identify "brainspots," which are eye positions that activate stored trauma or emotional pain in the brain.
Get to know me
In our first session together, here's what you can expect
I'll meet you right where you are. I help you to identify goals that you would want to accomplish in therapy, and hopefully build a relationship that you can be your authentic self.
The biggest strengths that I bring into our sessions
I create an environment where the Client will feel safe, and feel heard.
The clients I'm best positioned to serve
I love working with Clients who are looking to learn how to be the best versions of themselves.
Specialties
Top specialties
Anxiety
Depression
Perinatal Mental Health
Other specialties
Grief
Life Transitions
Mood Disorders
Peer Relationships
Postpartum
Racism
Self Esteem
Self-Harming
Suicidal Ideation
Trauma and PTSD
Identifies as
Black / African American
Woman
Serves ages
Adults (18 to 64)
Teenagers (13 to 17)
Licensed in
Indiana
Accepts
Aetna
Aetna - ASR Health Benefits
Aetna - Allied Benefits
Aetna - Lucent Health
Aetna - Luminare
Aetna - Moda
Aetna - WebTPA
Aetna – HealthEZ
All Savers
Ambetter Health
Amerihealth Administrators
Anthem
Blue Cross Blue Shield
Independence Administrators
Independence Blue Cross
Arlo
AvMed
Cash - $100 per session
Centivo
Cigna
Cigna - HealthEZ
EAP:Cigna
EAP:Evernorth
EAP:UnitedHealthcare/Optum
Evernorth
GTEB
Golden Rule
Harvard Pilgrim/UnitedHealthcare
Medicaid - Managed Health Services
Managed Health Services (Managed Medicaid)
UnitedHealthcare/Optum
Optum
OptumHealth Complex Medical Conditions
Oscar
Oxford
Surest (formerly Bind)
Tufts Health/Cigna
United Medical Resources
UnitedHealthcare Life Insurance
UnitedHealthcare Shared Services
UnitedHealthcare StudentResources
UnitedHealthcare/Optum - Medicaid
Location
Virtual
My treatment methods
Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)
Helping a Client to reframe their thoughts, how they are thinking.
Brainspotting
Where you look affects how you feel....helping a Client to tap into suppressed memories and emotions.
Christian Counseling
Helping a Client to heal based on their beliefs as well as incorporating Bible scriptures.
Dialectical Behavior (DBT)
Helping a Client to manage their emotions by using specific coping skills.
Mindfulness-Based Therapy
Helping a Client to understand how mind and body are connected.
6 ratings with written reviews
November 8, 2025
This was my first session with Crystal Kelly so I can only speak on the initial experience. Talking to Crystal Kelly was like talking to friend. She listened and validated me based on what I shared. I was jumping from one experience to another as I talked but she realized that I am a direct person. She gave me homework but pinpointed what she wanted specifically. I am looking forward to our next session.
Verified client, age 45-54
October 18, 2025
I love my sessions with Crystal Kelly because I always have something that I can take away from our sessions and implement them into my daily routine and that will empower me, help me to grow and overcome my fears.
Verified client, age 35-44
October 12, 2025
Dr. Kelly challenges me during every session, and I truly appreciate it. She pushes me to think deeper and step outside my comfort zone. Each meeting feels productive and helps me grow in meaningful ways. I can already see a difference in how I approach things. Her guidance and support have been invaluable. I’m really glad I found her.