Calm logo
Calm has teamed up with Grow Therapy to connect you with a mental health therapist who accepts your health insurance.
Rated 4.9 stars out of 5, 203 ratings

Nathan Macolly

LCSW, 20 years of experience

Holistic
Authentic
Solution oriented
Virtual
Next available on

About me

Welcome! With a Master’s in Social Work from the University of TN Knoxville in 2004, I've practiced therapy extensively with diverse populations. My empathetic, compassionate style blends coaching, accountability, and passion, meeting clients where they are. I embrace a holistic approach to wellness, focusing on mental, physical, and spiritual health (Whole Self Wellness), specializing in a Faith-Based (Christian) perspective. Neurodivergent affirming. Grateful for your consideration!

Get to know me

In our first session together, here's what you can expect

During our Initial Consultation, we typically cover the confidentiality policy, scheduling policies, followed by a discussion of therapy goals, to delve into the client's concerns. From here, we will discuss the Holistic model, to gain insight into my approach, ensuring alignment with their needs. Together, we'll assess if it's a "good fit." IF so, scheduling is encouraged and a homework assignment given.

The biggest strengths that I bring into our sessions

The holistic approach empowers clients to pursue optimal mental, physical, and spiritual well-being. As a provider, I collaborate with clients and meet them where they are on their journey to becoming healthier versions of themselves.

The clients I'm best positioned to serve

My approach integrates potent Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) strategies, empowering clients to embrace their authentic selves. While primarily CBT-based, my eclectic approach combines evidence-based methods for enhanced thought, mood, and behavior management. Emphasizing holistic wellness, clients stay engaged through progressive homework and assignments, fostering continual growth. I blend empathy, compassion, coaching, accountability, and passion, flexibly meeting clients where they are.

Specialties

Top specialties

Addiction
Anxiety
Depression

Other specialties

First Responders/Healthcare Workers
Spirituality
Trauma and PTSD

I identify as

Christian
Jewish
Man

Serves ages

Adults (18 to 64)
Elders (65 and above)
Teenagers (13 to 17)

My treatment methods

Christian Counseling

As a Holistic Provider, I collaborate with the Client to explore where the Psychology is Integrated with the Theology.

Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is the foundation that we build from in the Therapeutic Alliance.

Trauma Informed Care

Trauma Informed Care includes foundational CBT methods combined with potential Bilateral Brain Stimulation as needed, and assessed case by case.

Faith based therapy

As a Holistic Provider, I collaborate with the Client to explore where the Psychology is Integrated with the Theology.

Location

Offers in-person in 205 N Rhodes St, Monticello, FL 32344Virtual

Licensed in

Florida
Tennessee

Accepts

Aetna
Aetna - Luminare
Aetna - Medicare
Aetna - WebTPA
All Savers
Ambetter Health
AvMed
Blue Cross Blue Shield
Florida Blue
Anthem
Cash - $150 per session
Cigna
EAP:Cigna
EAP:Evernorth
EAP:UnitedHealthcare/Optum
Evernorth
Florida Blue - Medicare
Blue Cross Blue Shield - Medicare
Golden Rule
Harvard Pilgrim/UnitedHealthcare
Humana - Medicare
Humana Dual (Medicare & Medicaid)
UnitedHealthcare/Optum
Optum
OptumHealth Complex Medical Conditions
Oscar
Oxford
Surest (formerly Bind)
Tufts Health/Cigna
United Medical Resources
UnitedHealthcare Life Insurance
UnitedHealthcare Shared Services
UnitedHealthcare StudentResources
UnitedHealthcare/Optum - Medicare
Rated 4.9 stars out of 5, 203 ratings

18 ratings with written reviews

September 1, 2025

Nate is mental healer and a good one at that.

Verified client, age 55-64

Review shared after session 5 with Nathan

September 1, 2025

Nathan definitely fits in what I’m looking for in someone that relates to me and have a lot in common I’m glad I found him.

Verified client, age 25-34

Review shared after session 1 with Nathan

July 24, 2025

This was a great session. I will definitely rebook. His scope is not limited to counseling, but with strong biblical roots and physical training, and a nutritionist for a wife, he has insight and experience to serve the whole person. Blessings!

Verified client, age 35-44

Review shared after session 1 with Nathan