Nathan Macolly

LCSW, 21 years of experience
Holistic
Authentic
Solution oriented
VirtualAvailable

כֹּ֣ל הַ֭נְּשָׁמָה תְּהַלֵּ֥ל יָ֗הּ הַֽלְלוּ־יָֽהּ Welcome! I am a Licensed Clinical Social Worker (LCSW), alumni/graduate of the University of Tennessee, Knoxville (2002, 2004). Over the years, I’ve provided therapy and coaching to diverse populations, drawing from my background as a former coach, athlete, and ministry/chaplain to offer a grounded, relational, and purpose-driven approach to care. My style is empathetic, compassionate, and engaging — blending clinical expertise with coaching, accountability, and practical tools to meet clients where they are. I take a holistic approach to wellness, addressing mental, physical, and spiritual health, with a specialization in Faith-Based (Judeo - Christian) integration. Neurodivergent-friendly and committed to creating a respectful, supportive space for growth and healing, including for First Responders, those in Ministry, or dealing with Religious Trauma. Please read the full description before booking. Thank you for your consideration — I look forward to the possibility of working together.

Get to know me

In our first session together, here's what you can expect

During our Initial Consultation, we typically cover the confidentiality policy, scheduling policies, followed by a discussion of therapy goals, to delve into the client's concerns. From here, we will discuss the Holistic model, to gain insight into my approach, ensuring alignment with their needs. Together, we'll assess if it's a "good fit." IF so, scheduling is encouraged and a homework assignment given, before offering a closing prayer out the door. *Please be sure to review my profile and description carefully before scheduling an initial consultation to confirm awareness of services and services offered.

The biggest strengths that I bring into our sessions

The holistic approach empowers clients to pursue optimal mental, physical, and spiritual well-being. As a provider, I collaborate with clients and meet them where they are on their journey to becoming healthier versions of themselves.

The clients I'm best positioned to serve

My therapeutic approach integrates faith-informed Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) with a holistic, whole-person framework, helping clients cultivate renewal in mind, body, and spirit. While rooted in evidence-based practice, I draw upon experiential, somatic, and spiritual elements to promote genuine transformation and balance. Clients are supported through structured CBT tools, reflective assignments, and practical coaching to deepen awareness and sustain growth between sessions. Compassion, accountability, and authenticity form the foundation of our work together — empowering clients to uncover their true identity, align with their values, and walk in greater peace and purpose.

Specialties

Top specialties

Addiction

Anxiety

Depression

Other specialties

ADHD

First Responders/Healthcare Workers

Spirituality

I identify as

Christian

Jewish

Man

Serves ages

Adults (18 to 64)

Elders (65 and above)

Teenagers (13 to 17)

Licensed in

Florida

Accepts

Aetna

Location

Offers in-person in 205 N Rhodes St, Monticello, FL 32344

Virtual

My treatment methods

Christian Counseling

As a Holistic Provider, I collaborate with the Client to explore where the Psychology is Integrated with the Theology.

Cognitive Behavioral (CBT)

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy is the foundation that we build from in the Therapeutic Alliance.

Trauma Informed Care

Trauma Informed Care includes foundational CBT methods combined with potential Bilateral Brain Stimulation as needed, and assessed case by case.

Faith based therapy

As a Holistic Provider, I collaborate with the Client to explore where the Psychology is Integrated with the Theology.

, 264 ratings

30 ratings with written reviews

March 12, 2026

Has a “one size fits all” approach. Felt like he was reading from a script the whole time that he had repeated for every client he had. I spoke maybe 2 sentences the entire session, the rest was just him talking at me. Also he seemed to think the only way he could get worksheets and content to me was by making me purchase them off his etsy profile. Granted, he gave me a coupon for it but he also could have just emailed them to me so I suspect he was trying to boost his etsy sales.

Verified client, age 18-24
Review shared after session 2 with Nathan

March 11, 2026

I have had Nathan before as a therapist and took a break he warmly welcomed me back and at this stage of all the upheaval in my life I am grateful to have him as my therapist 🌻

Verified client, age 65+
Review shared after session 1 with Nathan

February 19, 2026

I so appreciated Nathan’s ability to listen and I think he is on point with his holistic approach to help people grow and look for solutions to overcome life’s challenges. He does a great job balancing his listening skills while finding a way to offer a healthy perspective and he communicates very well.

Verified client, age 35-44
Review shared after session 1 with Nathan